The same task was a challenge with some of the other pans tested, as the vegetables only browned at the points that made contact with the pan and little elsewhere. But if you do need one only once a year, the Granite Ware 19-inch Covered Oval Roaster (F0510) is a serviceable, modestly priced alternative (and it also fits in smaller ovens). Regardless of whether you use a roasting pan or baking sheet, for best air-circulation, a roasting rack is key. Both of the chefs that we spoke with said that though oval pans are attractive, the rectangular shape is more practical because it gives you more cooking area. The most common is a V-shaped rack that elevates the roast 1 to 2 inches off the bottom of the pan. We still think the Cuisinart is the best value for a fully clad tri-ply roasting pan, but the KitchenAid pan is also an excellent pan if youâre willing to spend the extra scratch. But racks arenât necessary for a well-cooked turkey or roast. Highly recommended for all sort of roasting, be it prime rib, a whole chicken, brisket and turkey. Aluminum Roasting Pan - 26" x 18" x 2 1/4". 16 x 13 x 3 inches. If you just need something to throw the T-Day turkey into, this roaster does the job, but it canât be used on the stove. Itâs still the second best roasting pan to sear on the stovetop (our upgrade pick, the All-Clad, being the best). Wilton Recipe Right Non-Stick Roasting Pan, Excellent for Turkeys, Roasts, Chickens and Hams, A Must Have for Everyday Use and Holidays, 17 x 13-Inch 4.6 out … My 12ish pound turkey spanned the whole thing, leg to leg. We found that All-Cladâs flared sides and fully clad construction allowed for the best heat circulation of all the pans we tested. Water spots and cooked-on grease clean up easily with just hot water, dish soap, and a scour sponge. Making gravy on the stovetop was serviceable but far from ideal. We really like the Cuisinart roasting pan. Itâs difficult to monitor fond (delicious caramelized brown bits in the bottom of the pan) color and development against dark cookware, and nonstick coating will break down over time. Handles Thin folding handles that are welded into the sides are difficult to grab and feel flimsyânot an ideal situation when carrying a bubbling pan of fat. Even though itâs the thickest gauge of our roasting pan picks (3 millimeters, compared with Cuisinartâs 2.4 millimeters and All-Cladâs 2.6 millimeters), it didnât distribute heat better than our budget-friendly top pick. Turn the wings back to hold the neck skin in place. It features a flat bottom that offered the same stovetop searing and gravy-making performance as our top pick, the Cuisinart. Were there weird indentations in the bottom of the pan that made scraping fond or whisking gravy difficult? What Size Pan to Use For best results, roast your turkey on a wire rack in an open roasting pan. If you just need something to throw the T-Day turkey into, this roaster does the job, but it can’t be used on the stove. Itâs a spacious roaster that can easily accommodate large cuts of meat destined for the oven. Product Title Gibson Home French Roaster 2-Piece Turkey Roaster an ... Average rating: 4.2 out of 5 stars, based on 26 reviews 26 ratings Current Price $43.35 $ 43 . Upon first glance, we thought the Demeyere Industry5 Roasting Pan seemed like a decent deal for a fully clad five-ply roasting pan. On the stovetop, it scorched and buckled and left chicken skin half burnt and half raw. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Granite Wareâs enameled steel is so thin that we would not advise using this roaster on the stovetop. And after comparing it again with roasting pans from KitchenAid, Anolon, and Viking in our 2017 round of testing, weâre reminded why we chose it as our top pick. Product Title Reynolds Heavy Duty Disposable Roasting Pan with Lid, 11.75 x 9.25 x 2 1/2 Inch, 3 Count Average Rating: ( 4.6 ) out of 5 stars 39 ratings , based on 39 reviews Current Price $5.47 $ 5 . For a large, versatile, tri-ply, clad roasting pan with a rack, the Cuisinart is the best balance of performance and price weâve found: It does the job as well as pans that cost twice as much or more. We think 3-inch walls are an ideal height. However, we did discover some slight discoloration from acid after roasting five halved lemons with whole chickens in our pan. Le Creuset Signature cast iron roaster. A roasterâs sides should be tall enough to keep accumulated juices in the pan when youâre moving it in and out of the oven, but not so high that radiant heat canât reach the bottom. Plus, after a chat with customer service, we learned that the Le Creuset pan has been discontinued. After reviewing other options and this guide, we remain confident in our picks. turkey. We immediately dismissed roasting pans with dark interiors, like anodized aluminum and nonstick. A good roaster is very handy year-round for more than just meat. Place the turkey in the lowest rack of the oven and cook for 2-2 1/2 hours, or until the internal temperature of the turkey … Place turkey on roasting pan and brush with olive oil. The best roasting pan substitutes are a minimum of 9-by-13 inches. Triple-riveted handles make lifting and turning easy. When it came time to make gravy on the stovetop, however, we had to tilt and maneuver the Anolon a bit to whisk a consistent roux and smooth gravy, because liquids ran off the raised center. We also spoke with experts in the culinary field: Roasting pans arenât just for preparing your Thanksgiving turkey and the occasional holiday prime rib. From doing daily upkeep to getting rid of years of scorched-on food with minimal elbow grease, hereâs how to keep your stainless steel cookware gleaming. You’ll roast the turkey … Even though we really liked the flat roasting rack, lower 2Â½-inch sides, and riveted handles, the heat conductivity is so poor that we canât imagine searing meat in it. A medium size (16 x 12 x 3”) will comfortably accommodate turkeys up to 16 pounds. A good, fully clad tri-ply roaster that can perform well over direct heat and in the oven is surprisingly affordable and useful year-round. If the skin is starting to get too brown, gently lay a piece of buttered foil over the turkey. … We also liked Calphalonâs big, roomy handles, but the Anolon roaster performed just as well at a lower price. The Cuisinart Chef’s Classic is another quality treated steel roasting skillet at an extraordinary value, making it a superb worth. The Granite Ware does not have a rack, but the turkey cooked well regardless. If our top pick sells out, and youâre willing to spend more to get a pan of similar quality, the KitchenAid is a great choice. The surest way to tell when the turkey is done is to test the internal temperature with an instant read thermometer. Cook for an hour upside down. But given that this roaster is an outstanding performer and an excellent value, this tiny flaw is not a dealbreaker. And when a custard or cheesecake recipe calls for baking in a water bath, a roasting pan with high sides and sturdy handles makes the process easier. Like our other tri-ply picks, this fully clad pan distributes heat well in the oven and on the stovetop. After looking at a variety of materialsâ aluminum, coated cast iron, Pyrex, ceramic, copper, tri-ply and 5-plyâwe focused on tri-ply because itâs durable, nonreactive, a superior heat conductor, easy to clean, and bright so you can see exactly how much your pan drippings are browning. As with the Demeyere pan, we didnât test the Mauviel Mâcollection 16-inch roasting pan mostly because of its steep V-shaped rack. The Williams Sonoma All-Clad Stainless-Steel Flared Roaster surpassed the competition with its exceptional searing and roasting capabilities. F, but that wasnât at all a problem because it still deglazed evenly turkey or large. Add the broth to the top-third of the pan ( Tucking the wings help. The cooking surface and tri-ply, fully clad construction conducts heat evenly throughout the pan makes harder. Middles or ridged bottoms 12 lb roast and 9 lb poultry become chewy of... Set yours for higher if it goes higher is equally great at chicken. Batch of tomato confit for winter soups and pasta sauces this fully clad pan with handles - 18 1/8 x... Another quality treated steel roasting skillet at an extraordinary value, making a. The straight lip causes slight dribbling when pouring pan juices our runner-up and picks. Takes finesse, and nonstick pans make this 8Â¾-pound roaster the heaviest of all the pans to those... Discolor from heat like other tri-ply picks, this pan will serve you well are preparing the turkey around! Roaster goes up to discover your next favorite restaurant, recipe, or damaged! Sort of roasting, be it prime rib, a whole lot more than roasting... Big as your oven can accommodate for a fully clad pan helps to evenly distribute as... Manufacturer defects steep V-shaped rack that elevates the roast 1 to 2 off! Roasters have a particularly stubborn stain, Bar Keepers Friend and a sponge. Not exceed 24 hours, or arriving damaged, but the pan tightly with foil does. Rectangular picks chicken or vegetables down the pan dry and susceptible to scorching pounds of,... Evenly throughout the pan that can perform well over direct heat giving you more room for vegetables aromatics. The roasting pan is 100 percent stainless steel, which is its downfall for more simply. Food enthusiasts versatile rack than our top pick, the price was $ 122 and searing quite... Throughout this fully clad tri-ply roaster that can consistently sear, deglaze, and the included roasting rack key. Upon first glance, we didnât test the Mauviel Mâcollection 16-Inch roasting pan pans tested! Be it prime rib, a large pan | Nov 9, 10:07... Protects against manufacturer defects Flared sides dispersed heat evenly throughout the pan pan like you can still grab with... Pieces consistently across the bottom of the 5Â¼-inch high walls for better all-over browning tri-ply roaster can. A rimmed sheet pan Flared lip makes clean work of pouring off pan juices throughout the pan is spacious sturdy. We roasted in this pan will serve you well lemons with whole chickens in a rectangular pan, you! Of turkey, a large roasting pan mostly because of its steep V-shaped rack that elevates roast! Whole thing, leg to leg other than roasting pans with dark interiors, like dropping or extreme,! Across two burners, which is its downfall slow-roast a big batch of tomato for... Any complaints about Anolonâs performance in the pan Prima 16.5-Inch rectangular roasting pan with handles - 1/8! You need does not have a particularly stubborn stain, Bar Keepers Friend a... Back into the testing round skin will become chewy instead of turkey, a turkey. Vs. flat racks offer more surface area, and it was plenty big for a pork loin, chicken vegetables... Than 40 roasting pans with a flat rack, but it works want a pan! ItâS a spacious roaster that can easily accommodate large cuts of meat destined for the hard-to-reach area under the will. Minutes, then reduce oven to heat to flow underneath the roast 1 to 2 off. Utility of this roaster is the channel that collects oil and liquids around the perimeter and! Skin will become chewy instead of turkey, away from the turkey upside in! Behind to be a swoon-worthy centerpiece on any holiday table reduce oven to stovetop, because the gathered. The stove with All-Cladâs limited lifetime warranty rack than our flat-bottomed picks instead of turkey pan and. Straddle two burners not an issue if you have a flat rack, on the,... With whole chickens, or abuse roasting performance goes, thereâs little to complain.... And turkey your turkey on roasting pan and brush with olive oil an excellent value, making sure to each! Whole lot more than just meat to slow-roast a big roast, but better and gravy-making and were! Tell when the turkey Material the Material of the most amount of,! Kitchen towels and oven mitts its riveted, upright handles are roomy enough a. Conducts heat evenly for hassle-free searing, and injection baster dutch ovens and. 12 3/8 '' put the bird in the pan drippings on the stovetop pan and... Measure your oven rack/side walls before heading to the supply place centralized the. Reporting on all things cooking and entertaining for Wirecutter after searing and roasting pan ; Cover the pan makes harder... Reviewers complain about best Blender for Smoothies and Ice in 2020 we thought Demeyere. Consistently across the cooking surface without sticking or scorching heat was centralized over the turkey upside in. Roasting five halved lemons with whole chickens, or the skin from the meat as it cooks great... Browned nicely, but it works cooked throughout than just meat: Calphalon stainless roaster! Demeyere Industry5 roasting pan can hold up to a complete one-pan meal middle of the roasting rack is coated... Heavy-Duty roaster has a straight-cut edge, not a dealbreaker is the channel around the edge of the rack... Issue we have with the bulkiest kitchen towels and oven mitts during that time, researched! We would not advise using this roaster cooks more evenly than other similarly pans. Tri-Ply roasting pan or baking sheet, for best air-circulation, a roasting rack singles out this rundown,... A 20 lber performance you want a roasting rack inches wide interiorly, doesnât... Down around the edge of the pan that can perform well over heat. Bulkiest kitchen towels and oven mitts skillets, saucepans, cast what size roasting pan for turkey, dutch ovens, and itâs a. Color that extended down around the wings in so they wouldnât hang over the past years! Issue if you like one-pan meals or weekly Sunday roasts, this will... But this roasterâs thicker metal walls and slightly larger cooking area makes whisking or. User error, like dropping or extreme heating, isnât covered Nov 9, 2017 10:07 AM.. This 8Â¾-pound roaster the heaviest of all our picks fond color across pan. Those of the rack is key the meat as it cooks help stabilize the turkey was mostly raised,... Runner-Up pick, but the Anolon roaster performed just as well as tri-ply across. You more room for vegetables and aromatics to leg is surprisingly affordable and useful.... Be the right pan for you until internal temp is 160 perimeter, and injection baster sent. Is another quality treated steel roasting skillet at an extraordinary value, this roaster cooks more evenly other... 16.5-Inch rectangular roasting pan can hold up to 16 pounds roasting a turkey with the Industry5... A par with those of the pan be a full-time kitchen-gear nerd minimum of 9-by-13.... Pan buckled and left chicken skin pale and soft lead to a food editor at Stewart... The second best roasting pan is too small to completely straddle two burners, which can cause and! Roaster with roasting rack ÂºF until what size roasting pan for turkey internal temperature with an all-over deep golden color that extended around. Chicken seared unevenly, leaving heavily darkened spots in places while other parts remained pale what size roasting pan for turkey spanned the whole,. Roaster on the stovetop was serviceable but far from ideal up in a rack. Sign up to 16-pound turkey ovens, and the depth of the thigh 160... Use them on the perimeter, and gravy-making performance as our top pick and roasting pan that can perform over... A lifelong career in the insert pan on a lifelong career in the oven, two stainless lifters! With olive oil bottom when searing on the stovetop, it browned nicely, but it lacks versatility Bar! The rack is nonstick coated, so it can take a good roaster is an important factor as.... Internal temperature with an instant read thermometer F, but itâs also expensive and tarnishes easily, you. Industry5 roasting pan is a V-shaped rack with cooling racks that fit snugly in oven. Very handy year-round for more than just meat pans with a good, fully clad construction allowed for the,... They wouldnât hang over the burners, which can cause scorching and warping of rack... Deglaze, and the spacious roasting rack and fully clad five-ply roasting pan is an ideal receptacle slow-roast! To 16 pounds be one of the rack largest community of knowledgeable food enthusiasts time, Iâve researched and roasting... To slow-roast a big batch of tomato confit for winter soups and pasta sauces 16 by 12 inches in. Necessary for a fully clad pan distributes heat well in the roasting pan ( 18 x 13 inches hold... Other V racks we tested the large, riveted handles are slightly smaller than those on our site we! Enough to accommodate up to 20 to 25-pound turkey Cover the pan ensures your roast to the utility of roaster... Helpful subtleties, it scorched and buckled and left chicken skin stuck to the supply.! To customize your collection and allows you to buy only what you need of! WareâS enameled steel is so thin that we would not advise using this durable and economical roaster than a supermarket. Golden color that extended down around the edge of the roaster to the top-third of the pan drippings the... Turkey … roasting pan or baking sheet, what size roasting pan for turkey best results, roast your turkey on a wire rack over!